SPORTS

Year-Round Youth Sports: A Love Letter to My Job Security

 

 

The same ACL tears and stress fractures keep arriving, just in smaller bodies without an off-season. 

Somewhere along the way, seasons disappeared. Now there's school ball, club ball, travel ball, showcase ball, and the plethora of "optional" training programs offered to you at a discounted price. For those of us in sports medicine, this equates to a steady stream of patients with similar diagnoses, just younger every year. 

 

In clinic, I see stress fractures in gymnasts and soccer players who should be worrying about spelling tests. I see medial epicondyle apophysitis in pitchers who threw a full game Saturday and a "light" bullpen Sunday. I see Sever's disease, Osgood-Schlatter, and ACL tears in kids who haven't had a real break since they started walking. These aren't just “part of the game." They are predictable overuse injuries in skeletons that are still growing, and growth plates are the weakest link in the chain. 

 

The data backs this up. Early single-sport specialization is associated with higher rates of overuse injury and burnout, with no convincing evidence that it improves the odds of elite success [3]. A commonly cited rule of thumb: if a child spends more hours per week in organized sport than their age in years, their injury risk climbs [2]. 

 

Behind every one of these injuries is a kid who loved their sport and now associates it with pain, surgery, or quitting. The parents and coaches aren't villains. They’re just part of a broken system, one whose main motivation has shifted over the past decade from developing kids to monetizing them. Most of them boarded for one good season, and the train never slowed down. The next station is always two tournaments away. Nobody chose the speed, and nobody wants to be the first to get off while everyone else rolls on toward the showcase. But the cost is real, and it's paid in cartilage, bone, and enjoyment of the game. 

 

Here's what gets lost at the showcase: the athletes at the very top mostly didn't specialize early. Patrick Mahomes was drafted in the 37th round in the 2014 MLB draft by the Detroit Tigers and also played basketball in high school. Tom Brady was drafted by the Montreal Expos in 1995 as a catcher before he ever threw an NFL pass. LeBron James was an all-state wide receiver. Bo Jackson and Deion Sanders made it to the pros in two sports. None of them got there by doing one thing twelve months a year. They got there with varied movement, real rest, and a love of playing. 

 

We all know that Michael Jordan didn’t only excel at basketball. "When the season ended, Michael left and played golf and didn't pick up a basketball again until probably a little bit before training camp [in September]," says Wally Blase, a Bulls athletic trainer from 1993-2000. "He might have played pickup ball with some friends, but he wasn't working eight hours a day at some gym with some shooting coach.” 

 

Since none of us are getting off this train anytime soon, here’s a few recommendations to make the ride smoother: 

  • Take 2 to 3 months off from any one sport each year. 
  • Build in at least one full rest day every week. 
  • Let your kid play more than one sport…and let them just PLAY with their friends outside! 
  • Proper warm-up and cool down; work on flexibility and mobility.  A thorough warm-up of at least 10 minutes should be performed including movement and stretching. 
  • Wear proper fitting equipment.   
  • Hydration and nutrition – before, during and after activities.  
  • Avoid playing the same position on multiple teams at the same time.  
  • Treat pain as information, not weakness.  If an athlete complains of pain that does not improve with 3 days of rest, it is time to seek the advice of a sports medicine provider [1]. 
  • Remember that very few of these kids will play in college, but all of them will need their bodies for the next 70 years. 

 

Job security is great, but honestly, I'd love to see fewer ACL tears in 11-year-olds. 

 

  1. https://www.sportsmed.org/sports-specialization-in-youth-athletes 
  1. Wu M, Fallon R, Heyworth BE. Overuse injuries in the pediatric population. Sports Med Arthrosc. 2016. Dec;24(4):150-158. 
  1. Post EG, Thein-Nissenbaum JM, Stiffler MR, Brooks MA, Bell DR, Sanfilippo JL, Trigsted SM, Heiderscheit BC, McGuine TA. High school sport specialization patterns of current Division I athletes. Sports Health. 2017. Mar/Apr;9(2):148-153. doi: 10.1177/1941738116675455. Epub 2016 Nov 3.